You do not have to be a foodie to know good pizza from bad pizza. Most of us can tell within the first bite if a place is worth going back to (and honestly, life is too short for disappointing pizza). Hendersonville has some surprisingly great spots for pizza, and after trying a lot of them over the years, these are the ones people keep returning to.
These are just the best pizza places in Hendersonville that consistently taste good, the ones people mention at school pickup or in the grocery line when someone says they need a dinner idea. Every place on here has its own thing it does well, and sometimes the thing it does well is saving you from cooking for the third night in a row.
If you want pizza in Hendersonville that is actually satisfying and not something you regret ordering, these seven places are a solid place to start (and you might even argue with someone later about which one deserves the top spot).
1. Pi Squared Pizza
Pi Squared is a household favorite and the place people talk about when they want pizza that feels a little more special without being complicated. Their square pizzas come out with cheesy edges that get slightly crispy (you know, the part everyone fights over). It always tastes fresh and filling, and because they offer vegetarian friendly, vegan friendly, and gluten free options, you can bring friends without having to solve a math equation to figure out who can eat what.
One family from Washington DC said they had been struggling to find good pizza after moving to Hendersonville and finally felt relieved when they found Pi Squared. They called it the best they had tried so far and said to order the mission figs because they were delicious. They even said they would be regular customers, which honestly says a lot. When people keep going back, it usually means the pizza is consistently good. It feels like the kind of place you trust when you are tired and do not want to gamble your dinner.
It has pretty much become a local go-to when people talk about pizza restaurants in Hendersonville. Whenever someone asks for a place that always delivers, Pi Squared is the one I hear mentioned first, mostly because it never lets anyone down.
2. West First Wood Fired
West First Wood Fired has this warm, cozy feel, the kind of place where you can finally sit down and breathe. The pizzas come out with a little char on the crust and toppings that taste fresh without trying too hard. It is reliable and relaxed. People love that they work with lots of dietary needs, which makes eating out so much easier. One reviewer summed it up by saying, “Best food ever, accommodates all dietary restrictions, and is purely fabulous.”
It is a great spot for when you want something that feels a little nicer without going full fancy. Everything tastes comforting in a way that makes you think, “Yes, this was a good decision,” which is honestly a pretty great feeling after a long day.
3. Mezzaluna
Mezzaluna has a little bit of everything and somehow makes pizza feel lighter without taking away the flavor. It is lively inside without being overwhelming, and the pizzas come out crisp and flavorful. It is an easy pizza restaurant to meet friends or take the family, even when no one can agree on anything.
Their Margherita gets a lot of love, but really, you cannot go wrong with anything on their menu. The whole experience feels pleasant, even when your day has not been. It is one of those Hendersonville pizza restaurants that just works for any occasion.
4. 2 Guys Pizza and Ribs
2 Guys Pizza and Ribs makes the kind of pizza that hits the spot without making you think too hard about it. The cheese melts nicely, the toppings actually cover the slice, and the flavors feel warm and familiar. It is comfort pizza at its finest.
The ribs are a fun twist here. They are surprisingly good and make this a great place for families or groups who want pizza but also want something extra. You leave full, happy, and possibly carrying leftovers (which is always the best kind of victory).
5. Joey’s New York Style Pizza
Joey’s makes New York style pizza in Hendersonville that tells you straight away it is going to be good. The crust folds the right way, the sauce has that classic taste, and the cheese stretches just enough without getting ridiculous. It is simple and straightforward (in the same way that dependable things usually are). If you like a true New York slice, you will probably end up adding this to your rotation.
It is great for quick bites. You can grab a slice, sit for a second, or take a whole pie home when the day has gotten away from you. Everything tastes fresh, the crust hits that perfect mix of soft and crisp, and the whole experience feels comforting (the kind of comforting that makes you forget you almost tried to cook tonight). It is one of those reliable places that always hits the spot.
6. Pellizzeri’s Pizza
Pellizzeri’s feels like the kind of place everyone grew up going to. The pizzas come out warm, cheesy, and simple in that nostalgic, familiar way. The crust is soft but sturdy, the toppings stay put, and it tastes exactly like what you hope for when you say you want pizza for dinner. It is a lovely option for family pizza night when you want something reliable and tasty, and it is definitely one of the more dependable pizza restaurants around town.
7. Uncle Maddio’s Pizza
Uncle Maddio’s is perfect for anyone who loves to customize their food. You pick your crust, sauce, and toppings, and they make it right there. It is fresh, easy, and ideal for families since no one has to compromise on toppings. The whole experience is quick and low stress (which honestly is the real goal on busy weeknights), making it one of the best quick bites when you need pizza in Hendersonville without the wait.
